Tallest: 2 · Year
By quarter-hour; stoppage time counts as the 45th or 90th minute.
Tallest: 1 · Minute
Cayman Islands's matches with known line-ups from their first recorded cap to their last.
| With them | 4 | 1 | 0 | 3 | 3 | 13 | 25% |
| Without them | 9 | 1 | 4 | 4 | 9 | 25 | 11.1% |
| Benjamin Maria | Aruba | 1 |
| Cardel Roberts | Antigua and Barbuda | 1 |
| Christopher Dilan | Puerto Rico | 1 |
| D'Andre Bishop | Antigua and Barbuda | 1 |
| Damil Dankerlui | Suriname | 1 |
| Daniel Bowry | Antigua and Barbuda | 1 |
| Dante Williams | Puerto Rico | 1 |
| Darren Ríos | Puerto Rico | 1 |
| Devin Vega | Puerto Rico | 1 |
| Diederick Luydens | Aruba | 1 |
| Aruba | 1 | 1 |
| Puerto Rico | 1 | 1 |
Finals and qualifying campaigns alike.
| 20 Nov 2023 | v Aruba | 1–5 | 49′ | — | Pulled one back | 1–2 | CONCACAF Nations League 2023 |
| 26 Mar 2023 | v Puerto Rico | 1–5 | 85′ | — | Pulled one back | 1–3 | CONCACAF Nations League 2023 |
In a recorded line-up, on the scoresheet or booked. “—” where the line-up isn't known.
| 8 Jun 2024 | v Antigua and Barbuda | 1–0 | started, off 86′ | 86 | — | — | FIFA World Cup qualification 2024 |
| 20 Nov 2023 | v Aruba | 1–5 | started, off 78′ | 78 | 1 | — | CONCACAF Nations League 2023 |
| 26 Mar 2023 | v Puerto Rico | 1–5 | started | 90 | 1 | Yellow | CONCACAF Nations League 2023 |
| 24 Mar 2021 | v Suriname | 0–3 | started, off 83′ | 83 | — | — | FIFA World Cup qualification 2021 |
Caps, goals and cards count what the sources record: line-ups from about 2003 (World Cups from 1970, friendlies from about 2016), and few scorers in older friendlies — so career totals run low.