Tallest: 1 · Year
By quarter-hour; stoppage time counts as the 45th or 90th minute.
Tallest: 1 · Minute
Cayman Islands's matches with known line-ups from their first recorded cap to their last.
| With them | 8 | 3 | 0 | 5 | 8 | 27 | 37.5% |
| Without them | 16 | 4 | 5 | 7 | 15 | 31 | 25% |
| Akeem Hill | Barbados | 2 |
| Hadan Holligan | Barbados | 2 |
| Hallam Hope | Barbados | 2 |
| Jett Blaschka | United States Virgin Islands | 2 |
| Jomo Harris | Barbados | 2 |
| Kassall Greene | United States Virgin Islands | 2 |
| Kishmar Primus | Barbados | 2 |
| Lionel Brown | United States Virgin Islands | 2 |
| Mario Williams | Barbados | 2 |
| Omani Leacock | Barbados | 2 |
Finals and qualifying campaigns alike.
| 17 Oct 2023 | v United States Virgin Islands | 2–1 | 57′ | — | Winning goal | 2–0 | CONCACAF Nations League 2023 |
In a recorded line-up, on the scoresheet or booked. “—” where the line-up isn't known.
| 6 Jun 2026 | v Gibraltar | 1–4 | started | 90 | — | — | Friendly |
| 7 Jun 2025 | v Honduras | 0–1 | started, off 90′ | 90 | — | Yellow | FIFA World Cup qualification 2025 |
| 4 Jun 2025 | v Bermuda | 0–5 | started | 90 | — | — | FIFA World Cup qualification 2025 |
| 17 Oct 2023 | v United States Virgin Islands | 2–1 | started, off 89′ | 89 | 1 | Yellow | CONCACAF Nations League 2023 |
| 29 Mar 2021 | v Canada | 0–11 | started, off 65′ | 65 | — | — | FIFA World Cup qualification 2021 |
| 19 Nov 2019 | v Barbados | 0–3 | started | 90 | — | — | CONCACAF Nations League 2019 |
| 8 Sep 2019 | v Barbados | 3–2 | started | 90 | — | — | CONCACAF Nations League 2019 |
| 5 Sep 2019 | v United States Virgin Islands | 2–0 | started | 90 | — | — | CONCACAF Nations League 2019 |
Caps, goals and cards count what the sources record: line-ups from about 2003 (World Cups from 1970, friendlies from about 2016), and few scorers in older friendlies — so career totals run low.