Own goals aside.
Tallest: 2 · Goals in the match
| 2 Jul 1916 | Final round | Chile | 0–4 | Uruguay |
| 6 Jul 1916 | Final round | Argentina | 6–1 | Chile |
| 8 Jul 1916 | Final round | Brazil | 1–1 | Chile |
| 10 Jul 1916 | Final round | Argentina | 1–1 | Brazil |
| 12 Jul 1916 | Final round | Brazil | 1–2 | Uruguay |
| 17 Jul 1916 | Final round | Argentina | 0–0 | Uruguay |
| Copa América 2024 | Argentina | 1–0 | Colombia | United States | 16 |
| Copa América 2021 | Argentina | 0–1 | Brazil | Brazil | 10 |
| Copa América 2019 | Brazil | 3–1 | Peru | Brazil | 12 |
| Copa América 2016 | Chile | 0–0 (pens) | Argentina | United States | 16 |
| Copa América 2015 | Chile | 0–0 (pens) | Argentina | Chile | 12 |
| Copa América 2011 | Uruguay | 3–0 | Paraguay | Argentina | 12 |
| Copa América 2007 | Brazil | 3–0 | Argentina | Venezuela | 12 |
| Copa América 2004 | Brazil | 2–2 (pens) | Argentina | Peru | 12 |
| Copa América 2001 | Colombia | 1–0 | Mexico | Colombia | 12 |
| Copa América 1999 | Brazil | 3–0 | Uruguay | Paraguay | 12 |
| Copa América 1997 | Brazil | 1–3 | Bolivia | Bolivia | 12 |
| Copa América 1995 | Uruguay | 1–1 (pens) | Brazil | Uruguay | 12 |