World Football Elo before kick-off, and what the result did to it.
Expected score for England: 53.3% (a draw counts half), home advantage included. An upset — the lower-rated side won.
Meeting 13 of 32, 1933–2023.
Before
After
Before
After
From England's side.
| 17 Oct 2023 | Italy | 3–1 | Home | UEFA Euro qualification 2023 | — |
| 23 Mar 2023 | Italy | 2–1 | Away | UEFA Euro qualification 2023 | — |
| 23 Sep 2022 | Italy | 0–1 | Away | UEFA Nations League 2022 | — |
| 11 Jun 2022 | Italy | 0–0 | Home | UEFA Nations League 2022 | — |
| 11 Jul 2021 | Italy | 1–1 (lost on pens) | Home | UEFA Euro 2021 | Final |
| 27 Mar 2018 | Italy | 1–1 | Home | Friendly | — |
| 31 Mar 2015 | Italy | 1–1 | Away | Friendly | — |
| 14 Jun 2014 | Italy | 1–2 | Neutral | FIFA World Cup 2014 | Group stage |
| 15 Aug 2012 | Italy | 2–1 | Neutral | Friendly | — |
| 24 Jun 2012 | Italy | 0–0 (lost on pens) | Neutral | UEFA Euro 2012 | Quarter-final |
| 27 Mar 2002 | Italy | 1–2 | Home | Friendly | — |
| 15 Nov 2000 | Italy | 0–1 | Away | Friendly | — |
| 11 Oct 1997 | Italy | 0–0 | Away | FIFA World Cup qualification 1997 | — |
| 4 Jun 1997 | Italy | 2–0 | Neutral | Tournoi de France 1997 | — |
| 12 Feb 1997 | Italy | 0–1 | Home | FIFA World Cup qualification 1997 | — |
| 7 Jul 1990 | Italy | 1–2 | Away | FIFA World Cup 1990 | Third-place play-off |
| 15 Nov 1989 | Italy | 0–0 | Home | Friendly | — |
| 6 Jun 1985 | Italy | 1–2 | Neutral | Friendly | — |
| 15 Jun 1980 | Italy | 0–1 | Away | UEFA Euro 1980 | Group stage |
| 16 Nov 1977 | Italy | 2–0 | Home | FIFA World Cup qualification 1977 | — |
Score: openfootball · Scorers: openfootball · Line-ups: none · Cards: none